Accuracy of tracking offline events Via Shopiy -> Zapier integration
Had a company setup Zapier to track offline conversions and I wanted to see if anyone else had experience using this setup. I’m assuming it matches click ID with ads served but it there is a black box between FB and Shopify so I was just curious if anyone else had any experience with this.
The short answer is:
Your suspicion is correct.
Using Zapier for this can be inaccurate because it often fails to capture and pass the critical click ID (
or fbclid
_fbc
cookie) from the user’s browser session to Facebook.
This forces Facebook to rely on matching user data like email and phone number, which is less precise.
A far superior and more reliable method is to implement the Facebook Conversions API using a server-side Google Tag Manager container, which is surprisingly cheap to run using a service like Stape.
The long answer is:
The “black box” you’re referring to is the gap between the user’s click on an ad and the final conversion data that Zapier sends from Shopify
When a user clicks a Facebook ad, Facebook adds a unique
parameter to the URL or stores a first-party fbclid
_fbc
cookie in their browser.
This is the most reliable way to attribute a conversion back to a specific ad click.
The problem with a standard Zapier setup is that it typically triggers when an order is created in Shopify’s backend.
At this point, the original browser session data – including that all-important click ID – is usually lost.
Zapier then sends customer details like email, name, and phone number to Facebook’s Offline Conversions endpoint.
While Facebook tries to match this information to a user profile, it’s a lower-quality signal and can easily miss matches or attribute them incorrectly, especially with Apple’s privacy changes.
An excellent and cost-effective solution is to use server-side tracking.
This involves setting up a client-side Google Tag Manager container on your Shopify store to capture events and user identifiers directly from the browser – including the _fbc
cookie.
This data is then sent not to Facebook directly, but to your own server-side GTM container.
This server container can be hosted very cheaply on a platform like Stape or Google Cloud Platform.
From this server environment, you can then send clean, enriched data directly to the Facebook Conversions API.
For a
event, you should configure a Shopify webhook (e.g., orders/create) to instantly send the order data to your server, which ensures you have the complete, reliable purchase details before sending the event to FacebookPurchase
This server-to-server connection is not affected by ad blockers or browser tracking restrictions.
This method gives you near-perfect data accuracy for events like
, AddToCart
, and InitiateCheckout
, improves event match quality significantly, and gives you full control over the data pipeline, all for what is often a much lower cost than a high-volume Zapier plan.Purchase