Question from user:
Hi guys. I run a marketing agency that helps home improvement companies with lead generation. We generate all the leads through Meta Ads, and then we also prequalify them and book them in for an appointment.
Although we’re getting some decent results, I run out of the ideas on how to increase lead quality.
I’ve tested pretty much everything; landing page, instant forms with 3+ questions, different ad creatives, different targeting options… and nothing seems to drastically increase lead quality.
Although we’re getting pretty low CPLs ($7-$15), I’d rather have a bit higher CPL but for higher quality leads.
Do you have any recommendations or tips on this?
I highly appreciate all the suggestions 🙌
Answer from Nabil:
The short answer is:
Since you’ve exhausted front-end testing on ads, forms, and targeting, the next step to drastically improve lead quality is to focus on the signal you’re sending back to the Meta advertising algorithm.
You need to expand the feedback loop beyond the basic Lead event to a much more valuable downstream event, such as a qualified appointment or a booked consultation.
This is achieved by using the Facebook Conversions API (CAPI) to send server-side data from your CRM back to Meta when a lead converts into a high-quality outcome, effectively telling the algorithm to find more users who are likely to reach that later, higher-value stage.
The long answer is:
It is completely understandable that you’re running out of ideas, as you’ve already implemented most of the common optimizations for home improvement lead generation, such as qualifying questions and testing different creatives.
Your feeling that you’d rather have a higher Cost Per Lead (CPL) for higher quality is absolutely correct because the real metric is Cost Per Qualified Appointment or Cost Per Sale.
The reason your CPL is low but quality is stagnant is because the Meta algorithm is very efficiently optimizing for the Lead event, but it has no information on whether that lead is actually a good fit for your clients’ business.
The algorithm is currently finding the cheapest people to fill out a form, not the best customers.
To solve this, you need to implement a strategy that leverages the Facebook Conversions API (CAPI) to communicate deeper sales funnel events back to Meta.
The process involves using a server-side solution like Google Tag Manager (GTM) Server Container, hosted on a platform such as Stape or Google Cloud Platform, to act as a secure intermediary between your Customer Relationship Management (CRM) system and Meta.
You would first ensure that the initial Lead event is tracked accurately using both the traditional Meta Pixel and the Conversions API for redundancy, which improves data reliability and Event Match Quality.
The crucial step, however, is to create a new custom conversion event that corresponds to a highly-qualified lead action.
For a home improvement agency, this would be an event like Appointment_Booked or Qualified_Lead_MQL.
When a lead moves from the submission stage to the booked appointment stage in your CRM, your server-side environment (using CAPI) sends this Appointment_Booked event back to Meta, along with all the customer data (email, phone number, name) you collected from the form.
This is an extremely high-quality signal.
You then switch your campaign optimization away from the generic Lead event and target the new, higher-value Appointment_Booked event.
This forces the Meta machine learning model to radically shift its targeting to find people who are not just likely to fill out a form, but who are specifically likely to become a booked appointment, resulting in a dramatic increase in lead quality, even if the CPL increases slightly.
By using a server-side setup via GTM and CAPI, you bypass client-side issues like ad blockers and browser privacy restrictions, ensuring the most accurate, reliable, and privacy-safe data is used to train the algorithm for genuine business outcomes.
About The Author
